Concept:Use the sums obtained from the averages and the ordering of ratings to test which statement cannot be true.
Explanation:Sort the ratings as
r1≤r2≤⋯≤r8.
Total sum of all ratings is
30×8=240.
Sum of the top five ratings is
38×5=190, so
r4+r5+r6+r7+r8=190.
Sum of the lowest five ratings is
25×5=125, so
r1+r2+r3+r4+r5=125.
Thus,
r6+r7+r8=240−125=115.
And
r1+r2+r3=240−190=50.
So
r4+r5=190−115=75.
The median is
2r4+r5=275=37.5, so option B is definitely true.
Now check option D: suppose the highest rating is
r8=40.
Then
r6+r7=115−40=75.
Since
r6≤r7, this forces
r6≤37.
Therefore
r5≤r6≤37, and because
r4≤r5, we get
r4+r5≤74.
This contradicts
r4+r5=75, so the highest rating cannot be 40.
Options A, C and E are not definitely false.
For example, the ratings
1,12,37,37,38,38,38,39 satisfy all given conditions; here the second highest is
38, the lowest is
1, and the third lowest is
37.
Answer:Option D: The highest rating obtained is 40 is definitely false.